Sub_Zero wrote:All what Ace is saying is absolute truth. Glad that someone shares my vision of the situation. How can these facts be denied?
What facts? I wasn't under the impressions that opinions = fact
Again, strawman, it's just impossible to have a discussion with you is it?
No, I'll glady have a discussion about something. But when you continously bring up irrelevant unit comparisons for the sake of trying to win an arguement, it really get's frustrating. I've expressed and made myself clear about this several times, yet you won't abide by that, and you expect me to really to care?
See, I care more about post that are more along the lines of this;
- Concrete and perspective analysis of the Vanguard design & implementation
- Reasoning why Vanguards are failing to perform for their cost & effiency
WITHIN the Space Marine army composition and "meta"
- Video/Replays both featuring Vanguards useage. You can get a better sense from where people are coming from, and which you can either acknowledge that the player made outside-mistakes that made them falter in performance. Not neccasarily the units performance being bad.
What I don't care about
- Why can't my Vanguards beat Seer Council/Nob/Terminators?
- Why get Vanguards when I can get Terminators?
For the sake of it, I'll let people think about why I don't give two squats about the two I listed above. It's probably more to it, but I don't feel making a bigger thing out of it.
Vanguards, much alike Sternguards and misc. other units for other factions, are meant to be situational. Even Terminators are meant to be abit of a situational purchase. I've seen games when they win, and I've witnessed when they were a dreadful purchase. That's a better striking balance compared to "Well I'll just get Terminators and I'll be a breeze from here on, since they're the better unit out of all the options I've got". The purchases are meant to be strategical, and preference.
Now, I think it's safe to say, Vanguards don't see much use. You get one bad game with it, and then you don't ever get them again. Eventho maybe it all actually just boiled down to mistakes, and they actually have a much better effiency then they get credited for.
This all gets very problematic when you want to balance things, because things can get messy, and they can get messy fast. I see talk about them, yet I rarely see even people get them in the first place when I'm either playing games, or watching games. So that strikes me more of an odd experience of "I had a bad game with them, so I'm not going to even try to make them work" - which is both bad feedback for me, which results in bad balance & gameplay for everyone else.
I need more constructive, yet keeping it simple to the overall army compositions and what you're going up against with them to get a better sense of an idea on where things are problematic. For an example, if Terms/Vanguards are struggling to get through frontlines, you know there's a problem along the lines of CC (Player mistakes might be an issue here) or if they just don't perform well enough in general combat effiency.
So the direction and what needs adjusting is important. Are they faltering due to CC, or faltering due to general combat effiency values. There are more factors, but those are some basic guidelines that I want to look for when I want to adjust something. The past buffs for say, Vanguards are more straight up combat-effiency + sustain effiency. Prolonging the capability to gain experience, and level up with them. Since they have a better pay-off to some degree with the levels they get. (It's 10% compared to previous 15%) but the overall benefits are roughly still the same however with the flat-hp boost they got as well. The big bonus is the health regeneration, which makes small-arms fire really pathetic against them.
Elaborate.
You're wrong on the Kaskrin cost as well. By quite abit as well. They're 450/45. You mentioned their pricing to be ~400/40 two times, and both times - you were wrong. All you have to do, if you're uncertain about the price of a unit, is to boot the game and check it out.