I don't know, it seems to me that spotters won't be as good vs GK seeing as GK are a very mobile race. for me catachans work better almost every time.

how exactly do spotters work well vs. GK?

well, disagreeing is fine, i just wanted to start a discussion about some questions i had.
thank you all for the thoughtful comments!

That strat was popular around the midlife point of vanilla. not so much anymore. to tell you the truth, i'm not sure what changed it, probably some number adjustments. but i guess now it just comes down to opinion. i find it hard to justify a 400\50 squad that doesn't pose a real threat to SUTs, and...

Still, for such a high cost squad they feel very underwhelming to me, what with not being an actual high damage threat nor being able to hold their on when counter initiated.

They are doing good damage actually. Their purpose is to jump into ranged units and tie them up, and to knockback when you want. Yes I do such thing. They are quite enough for Devs, Havocs, Lootas, etc. Also, a real good unit to tie up other ranged units like Tacs, Guardians, even CSM which has the...

They are actually great. For T1 they have a good armor type and a huge health pool. They are durable enough to perform a second assault jump before losing models. Sometimes you use it to retreat and sometimes you continue breaching their lines. In T2 they get an invaluable ability to deter all thes...

1. Why would you get Aspect of Swiftness instead of Strength on banshees? surely, a bit more dps isn't equal to a superior damage type. 2. Are ASM a bit weak right now? I feel like they can't beat any other melee unit in melee combat, even ones that are much cheaper. they can't seem to beat even slu...