Page 1 of 1
					
				Is Storm Shield too good in tier 1?
				Posted: Thu 10 Dec, 2015 12:24 am
				by bibotot
				Force Commander charges straight into HMG team. Ties them up. Takes only 50% HP damage during the charge. Still has 50% energy left. And this buff applies to anyone close to him.
Honestly, who would buy the Iron Halo in tier 1 anymore? This wargear is ridiculous. It counters all HMG teams, Banshees and Raptors.
			 
			
					
				Re: Is Storm Shield too good in tier 1?
				Posted: Thu 10 Dec, 2015 12:33 am
				by Asmon
				Or perhaps it doesn't? Who knows...
			 
			
					
				Re: Is Storm Shield too good in tier 1?
				Posted: Thu 10 Dec, 2015 12:37 am
				by Oddnerd
				I havent found it OP in my experience as an IG main.  It also slows them down, which can be exploited if your micro is ok.
One of the worst designs in this game is the 1-man-army offensive commander, so any item like a stormshield that makes them less 1-dimensional is great and I wouldn't want to discourage its use by nerfing it.
			 
			
					
				Re: Is Storm Shield too good in tier 1?
				Posted: Thu 10 Dec, 2015 5:20 am
				by Aguxyz
				Storm Shield is fine just focus fire FC
			 
			
					
				Re: Is Storm Shield too good in tier 1?
				Posted: Thu 10 Dec, 2015 2:48 pm
				by Adeptus Noobus
				Ahem, it also means he is slower, more susceptible to disruption (e.g Spotters) and he does not have enough energy for his most annoying ability: battle cry. That means no more special attacks on your hero or units and no more stacking damage buff with each attack he does. That is quite significant if you ask me.
			 
			
					
				Re: Is Storm Shield too good in tier 1?
				Posted: Thu 10 Dec, 2015 2:54 pm
				by DandyFrontline
				Hey, i remember the same post few months ago.
			 
			
					
				Re: Is Storm Shield too good in tier 1?
				Posted: Thu 10 Dec, 2015 2:56 pm
				by Adeptus Noobus
				DandyFrontline wrote:Hey, i remember the same post few months ago.
And also that. This has been discussed at length before and the Storm Shield was nerfed afterwards.
 
			
					
				Re: Is Storm Shield too good in tier 1?
				Posted: Thu 10 Dec, 2015 4:21 pm
				by Atlas
				Aguxyz wrote:Storm Shield is fine just focus fire FC
Qft.
The halo is super good vs ig actually. Artificer and halo vs ig will let fc tank all day , gain tons of xp and absolutely forces a setup team in response. 
I personally think SM vs IG is a little IG favored in general, but definitely playable. 
More levels earlier equals more devastating TH later. Yes plz.
 
			
					
				Re: Is Storm Shield too good in tier 1?
				Posted: Fri 11 Dec, 2015 3:17 pm
				by Superhooper01
				Me and cornholio have also made  a post of this btw.
			 
			
					
				Re: Is Storm Shield too good in tier 1?
				Posted: Fri 11 Dec, 2015 5:04 pm
				by saltychipmunk
				Aguxyz wrote:Storm Shield is fine just focus fire FC
Doesnt the fc also get really tanky with the storm sheild?
he gets an extra 100 hp and another 20% passive ranged damage resistance , you throw in the artificer armor and you are looking at a  1120 hp commander with decent hp regen as well before even considering the active ability defend.
add in the 50% ranged damage reduction and all he need do to become ridiculously hard to kill is move h from cover to cover   or even just have him behind his army  a decent bit.
Id think a better method to deal with him is just make him waste his energy.   even with artificer  he doesnt have an endless energy pool and if you keep forcing him to toggle the sheild  (by running out of range)  he will burn through the energy even faster. 
though if you end up defending your gen farm from a full energy ss fc  you better start tying shit up or  the  inevitable flame tac is going to  melt it  while laughing at your  set up teams and ranged blobs.
 
			
					
				Re: Is Storm Shield too good in tier 1?
				Posted: Fri 11 Dec, 2015 7:33 pm
				by Aguxyz
				saltychipmunk wrote:Aguxyz wrote:Storm Shield is fine just focus fire FC
Doesnt the fc also get really tanky with the storm sheild?
he gets an extra 100 hp and another 20% passive ranged damage resistance , you throw in the artificer armor and you are looking at a  1120 hp commander with decent hp regen as well before even considering the active ability defend.
add in the 50% ranged damage reduction and all he need do to become ridiculously hard to kill is move h from cover to cover   or even just have him behind his army  a decent bit.
Id think a better method to deal with him is just make him waste his energy.   even with artificer  he doesnt have an endless energy pool and if you keep forcing him to toggle the sheild  (by running out of range)  he will burn through the energy even faster. 
though if you end up defending your gen farm from a full energy ss fc  you better start tying shit up or  the  inevitable flame tac is going to  melt it  while laughing at your  set up teams and ranged blobs.
 
Everyone still takes full melee dmg, support shees while they do all the work all you'll be fine
 
			
					
				Re: Is Storm Shield too good in tier 1?
				Posted: Fri 11 Dec, 2015 7:39 pm
				by egewithin
				Aguxyz wrote:Everyone still takes full melee dmg, support shees while they do all the work all you'll be fine
Wow! I didn't realize that before, thanks a lot!
 
			
					
				Re: Is Storm Shield too good in tier 1?
				Posted: Fri 11 Dec, 2015 8:17 pm
				by Dullahan
				I've been saying it was awesome for YEARS.  If you micro the defend ability to only be active during the burst from the heavy bolter you barely lose any energy/speed and can charge the suppression team easily.
It's not "too good" though, it's just strong at what it does.
			 
			
					
				Re: Is Storm Shield too good in tier 1?
				Posted: Fri 11 Dec, 2015 8:21 pm
				by Adeptus Noobus
				You can still toggle it on and off but it is ill advised as the activation costs 10 power now.
			 
			
					
				Re: Is Storm Shield too good in tier 1?
				Posted: Fri 11 Dec, 2015 8:42 pm
				by Dullahan
				Adeptus Noobus wrote:You can still toggle it on and off but it is ill advised as the activation costs 10 power now.
Power as in the resource?  Or energy?
If energy:
That's a smart change, glad to see.  Still worth toggling it I think, but atleast it's not free.  30 energy  to run up quickly on it is about the same as if you walked up on it.
if power:
lol.
 
			
					
				Re: Is Storm Shield too good in tier 1?
				Posted: Fri 11 Dec, 2015 10:17 pm
				by Dark Riku
				It's indeed energy as you assumed 

 
			
					
				Re: Is Storm Shield too good in tier 1?
				Posted: Sat 12 Dec, 2015 1:16 am
				by Adeptus Noobus
				Dark Riku wrote:It's indeed energy as you assumed 

 
Yeah, I meant energy ofc. XD
 
			
					
				Re: Is Storm Shield too good in tier 1?
				Posted: Sat 12 Dec, 2015 4:21 pm
				by egewithin
				Thankfully it is energy.
			 
			
					
				Re: Is Storm Shield too good in tier 1?
				Posted: Sat 16 Jan, 2016 1:17 pm
				by CSM Emperor
				bibotot wrote:Force Commander charges straight into HMG team. Ties them up. Takes only 50% HP damage during the charge. Still has 50% energy left. And this buff applies to anyone close to him.
Honestly, who would buy the Iron Halo in tier 1 anymore? This wargear is ridiculous. It counters all HMG teams, Banshees and Raptors.
i never had trouble dealing with FC who used shield.
 
			
					
				Re: Is Storm Shield too good in tier 1?
				Posted: Sat 16 Jan, 2016 6:27 pm
				by Black Relic
				That is because if you play Chaos you should have a hard time. but races like eldar will due to a lot of their damage t1 stems from guardians and shees. And shees vs SM is a bit difficult when facing it head on. But that is way you flank SM as much as possible.
Chaos has a ton of melee in t1 and Heretics can deal with him pretty well since if he uses battle cry there goes his energy and instantly suppressed. Now you can just back you heretics up and focus fire him. Reduce your bleed and force off the FC. If he doesn't then you keep smacking him in melee, that's the simple explanation.
			 
			
					
				Re: Is Storm Shield too good in tier 1?
				Posted: Sun 17 Jan, 2016 12:00 am
				by CSM Emperor
				Black Relic wrote:That is because if you play Chaos you should have a hard time. but races like eldar will due to a lot of their damage t1 stems from guardians and shees. And shees vs SM is a bit difficult when facing it head on. But that is way you flank SM as much as possible.
Chaos has a ton of melee in t1 and Heretics can deal with him pretty well since if he uses battle cry there goes his energy and instantly suppressed. Now you can just back you heretics up and focus fire him. Reduce your bleed and force off the FC. If he doesn't then you keep smacking him in melee, that's the simple explanation.
you are imagining things, i play totally different.
 
			
					
				Re: Is Storm Shield too good in tier 1?
				Posted: Sun 17 Jan, 2016 12:30 am
				by Black Relic
				Then you should explain and not make one liners in a balance section.
			 
			
					
				Re: Is Storm Shield too good in tier 1?
				Posted: Sun 17 Jan, 2016 3:09 am
				by Tranca
				I wanna put in one of those #rekt gifs, because it would be funny as hell. 
Can someone do that? I'm scared of trying and looking bad.
This one is funny: 

 
			
					
				Re: Is Storm Shield too good in tier 1?
				Posted: Sun 17 Jan, 2016 5:06 am
				by Atlas
				Let's keep this on topic, shall we?